Best Mattress Firmness for Back Pain: Sleep Your Way to Relief

Reviewed by: Dr. Steven Knauf, D.C.

By: Janett King

If you wake up with back pain, your mattress could blame you. Many people don’t realize that mattress firmness plays a significant role in spinal alignment and overall comfort while you sleep. Choosing the right mattress firmness is essential, especially when dealing with discomfort, stiffness, or chronic pain.

In this guide, we’ll dive into everything you need to know about mattress firmness and how to find the ideal mattress for back pain. We’ll explore the firmness levels, the relationship between your sleep position and mattress type, and expert tips for selecting a mattress that supports your body’s unique needs. Along the way, we’ll bust some common myths, offer actionable recommendations, and break down the factors influencing your decision.

The importance of spinal alignment for back pain relief

Spinal alignment plays a crucial role in how well you sleep and how you feel when you wake up. Your spine has a natural curve; when that curve is supported correctly, your muscles can relax, and your body can recover overnight. But when your spine is out of alignment while you sleep, it can lead to stiffness, soreness, and chronic back pain.

When a mattress doesn’t support your spine correctly, your body compensates, often leading to discomfort in key areas like the lower back, shoulders, and hips. The effects depend on the type of misalignment:

• Too soft of a mattress: When your mattress lacks support, your body may sink too much, especially around your midsection. This can cause an unnatural curve in the lower back, increasing strain on the lumbar spine and causing pain.
• Too firm of a mattress: A too rigid mattress may not allow your spine’s natural curves to rest comfortably. Instead of supporting the body evenly, it can create pressure points in areas like the shoulders, hips, and lower back, leading to pain and stiffness.
• Worn-out or sagging mattress: A mattress that has lost its structural integrity can cause uneven support, leading to poor sleep posture and worsening back pain.

How a supportive mattress may help with your back pain

A mattress that keeps your spine in a neutral position can reduce strain on your muscles and joints, helping to prevent or relieve back pain. The right level of support allows your muscles to relax and your spine to stay in proper alignment throughout the night so you don’t wake up sore.

A well-matched mattress should:

• Distribute weight evenly so no single area of the body bears too much pressure.
• Support the spine’s natural curvature by keeping the lower back from sinking too much or the hips and shoulders from pressing uncomfortably into the mattress.
• Promote better sleep posture by helping you maintain a neutral spinal position in your preferred sleep position.

Since everyone’s body is different, the ideal mattress for back pain isn’t one-size-fits-all. Factors like sleep position, body weight, and mattress firmness all play a role in finding the best fit. In the following sections, we’ll explain how to match your mattress to your needs for the best spinal support and comfort.

Types of mattresses and their pros and cons

The right mattress can make or break your sleep quality. With so many options available, it’s crucial to understand how different materials and constructions affect comfort, support, and overall spinal alignment. Below is a detailed breakdown of mattress types, benefits, and potential drawbacks.

Memory foam mattresses

Memory foam mattresses are made from viscoelastic polyurethane foam, originally developed by NASA to absorb impact. These mattresses conform to your body by responding to heat and pressure, allowing your spine to stay aligned while relieving stress on joints and muscles.

Memory foam is a top choice for people suffering from pressure-related discomfort, such as joint pain, arthritis, or back issues. Since the foam molds to your body, it helps distribute weight evenly and minimizes motion transfer, which is great if you share a bed with a partner.

Pros

• Exceptional pressure relief, making it ideal for side sleepers and those with joint pain
• Absorbs motion, reducing disruptions from a restless partner
• Molds to the body for a snug, contoured feel

Cons

• Can trap heat, making it less ideal for hot sleepers unless infused with cooling technology
• Slower response time, meaning it may take a few seconds to return to its original shape when changing positions
• Can feel too soft for stomach sleepers who need extra firmness

Gel-infused memory foam mattresses

Gel memory foam mattresses are designed to combat the biggest drawback of traditional memory foam—heat retention. These mattresses incorporate gel beads or layers of cooling gel to help dissipate body heat and regulate temperature.

If you love the feel of memory foam but tend to sleep hot, gel-infused models provide a more breathable option. While they don’t eliminate heat retention, they offer a noticeable improvement over standard memory foam.

Pros

• Same contouring and pressure relief as memory foam but with better temperature regulation
• Absorbs motion for uninterrupted sleep
• Available in various firmness levels to suit different sleep positions

Cons

• The cooling effect may fade over time as the gel disperses
• Can still feel too soft for stomach sleepers who need firmer support
• Often comes at a higher price point than standard memory foam

Innerspring mattresses

Innerspring mattresses have metal coils that provide a traditional, bouncy feel. Unlike foam mattresses, which contour closely to the body, innerspring beds focus on providing firm, structured support.

These mattresses are great for people who prefer a responsive surface without feeling “stuck.” They also tend to sleep cooler due to increased airflow between the coils. However, they don’t provide as much pressure relief as foam mattresses and can sometimes feel too firm for certain sleepers.

Pros

• Firm, supportive feel that works well for stomach and back sleepers
• Allows for better airflow, making it a cooler option for hot sleepers
• More responsive than foam, making movement easier

Cons

• Less contouring and pressure relief than foam mattresses
• Motion transfer can be high, meaning a restless partner might disturb your sleep
• Springs may wear out over time, leading to sagging and reduced support

Hybrid mattresses

Hybrid mattresses combine the support of an innerspring system with the cushioning of foam, latex, or gel layers. This design balances support and comfort, making it versatile for different sleep preferences.

Since hybrids feature a mix of materials, they can provide the best of both worlds: the responsiveness and airflow of innerspring with the contouring and pressure relief of foam or latex. Many hybrid mattresses are built with zoned support, meaning different mattress sections have varying firmness levels to support various body areas better.

Pros

• Balanced support and cushioning for a variety of sleep positions
• Good airflow, keeping sleepers cooler than all-foam models
• Less motion transfer than traditional innerspring mattresses

Cons

• Can be heavier and more difficult to move
• Higher price point compared to foam or innerspring mattresses
• Foam layers may still retain some heat, depending on the materials used

Latex mattresses

Latex mattresses use natural or synthetic rubber to provide a firm but responsive sleep surface. Unlike memory foam, which slowly conforms to the body, latex offers a more buoyant feel while relieving pressure points.

Natural latex is hypoallergenic, resistant to dust mites, and highly durable, making it an excellent long-term investment. It’s also one of the most breathable mattress materials, making it a solid choice for hot sleepers.

Pros

• Naturally breathable and temperature-regulating
• Durable, with a lifespan often exceeding 10 years
• Provides a balance of contouring and support for proper spinal alignment

Cons

• Expensive compared to other mattress types
• May feel too firm for sleepers who prefer a plush, sinking-in sensation
• Some people are sensitive to the initial latex smell, though it dissipates over time

Adjustable air mattresses

Unlike traditional air mattresses used for temporary sleeping arrangements, high-end adjustable air mattresses allow you to customize firmness levels by increasing or decreasing air pressure.

Some models even offer dual zones, so couples can adjust each side of the bed individually. Adjustable air mattresses are particularly beneficial for people whose firmness preferences change over time. For example, those recovering from injuries or dealing with fluctuating back pain may benefit from being able to modify their mattress firmness as needed.

Pros

• Customizable firmness levels for personalized comfort
• Ideal for couples with different sleep preferences
• Lightweight and easier to move compared to foam and hybrid mattresses

Cons

• Can be expensive, especially for models with advanced features
• Mechanical components may require maintenance or repairs
• May not provide the same contouring as foam or hybrid mattresses

Choosing the right mattress starts with understanding the materials and how they affect comfort, support, and durability. Each type has its strengths and drawbacks; what works best for one person may not be ideal for another. As we continue this guide, we’ll dive deeper into how mattress firmness, sleep position, and body weight all play a role in finding the best mattress for back pain.

What is the mattress firmness scale?

Before diving into mattress recommendations, it's crucial to understand mattress firmness and how it impacts your back pain. The mattress firmness scale typically ranges from 1 to 10, with 1 being extremely soft and 10 being extra firm.

Mattress firmness scale

Soft mattress (1-3): Soft mattresses feel plush and sink in quite a bit. It is best for people who sleep on their sides or need cushioning for joint pain. These are often best for side sleepers or individuals with joint pain, as they cushion sensitive pressure points. However, they may not provide enough support for spinal alignment if you suffer back pain or significantly lower back pain.

Medium mattress (4-6): Medium mattresses offer a balance of softness and support. They are ideal for back sleepers or those with moderate back pain. This is the most common choice for back sleepers and those with moderate back pain. They balance comfort and support well, which is vital for spinal alignment.

Firm mattress (7-9): Firm mattresses provide more rigidity, providing support with less sinking. They are excellent for stomach sleepers or people with more severe back issues. They help prevent the spine from sinking too much, keeping it aligned and reducing strain.

Extra firm mattress (10): Extra firm mattresses offer maximum support, though they can feel too rigid for some sleepers. They offer the most support, but they can be uncomfortable for some, especially those who need cushioning for joint pain. It’s critical to assess your pain points before opting for this firmness.

To determine which firmness will best relieve your back pain, it’s crucial to consider your sleep position, pressure points, and body weight. When we talk about finding the best mattress for back pain, it’s about the combination of support and comfort that aligns the spine and relieves pressure on the lower back, hips, and shoulders.

Identifying your sleep position

Your sleep position is how your body naturally settles during the night, while sleep posture refers to how well that position supports your spine, muscles, and joints. Even if your position feels comfortable, poor sleep posture—like a misaligned spine, uneven pressure distribution, or excessive twisting—can contribute to pain and stiffness. Learning how you sleep and the difference between position and posture can help you adjust for better rest.

Most people fall into one of four primary sleep positions, though how your body is supported within that position can determine whether it helps or harms your sleep quality.

Back sleeping

Sleeping on your back allows for a neutral spine position, making it one of the best positions for overall spinal health, as long as your mattress and pillow provide the right level of support. A well-supported back sleeper will have their head, shoulders, and hips aligned, with no excessive arching in the lower back.

However, if the mattress is too firm or soft, gaps can form between the body and the bed, leading to uneven pressure and strain. Additionally, back sleeping can worsen snoring and sleep apnea since gravity naturally pulls the tongue and soft tissues toward the airway, leading to potential blockages.

People who sleep on their backs may benefit from a supportive pillow that keeps the head in a neutral position and a mattress that allows for slight contouring while offering even weight distribution.

Side sleeping

Side sleeping is one of the most common positions. When done correctly, side sleeping supports spinal alignment and reduces issues like acid reflux and snoring. The key to good sleep posture in this position is aligning the head, shoulders, and hips.

Without the right support, side sleepers often experience excessive pressure on their shoulders and hips, leading to discomfort and pain. A pillow that supports the head and neck can help maintain a neutral position, while a mattress with enough cushioning can reduce pressure on the joints and prevent pain.

Side sleepers also need to be mindful of leg positioning. Keeping the top leg stacked over the bottom leg helps prevent spinal twisting. Some people may even place a pillow between their knees to maintain hip alignment and reduce strain on the lower back.

Stomach sleeping

Stomach sleeping is the least ideal position for spinal health, as it places excessive pressure on the neck and lower back. Since the head has to turn to one side to allow for breathing, the neck remains rotated for long periods, which can cause stiffness and discomfort.

Additionally, stomach sleeping can create an exaggerated arch in the lower back, leading to tension and strain. A too soft mattress can make this worse by allowing the stomach to sink in too much, forcing the spine into an unnatural curve.

Some people find stomach sleeping comfortable, especially if they struggle with snoring or mild sleep apnea. If stomach sleeping feels best, a thin pillow (or none) and a firmer mattress can help reduce excessive spinal arching and neck strain.

Combination sleeping

Combination sleepers move between two or more positions throughout the night, shifting between back, side, and sometimes stomach sleeping. This dynamic way of sleeping can relieve pressure and help avoid stiffness from staying in one position too long. However, finding the right mattress and pillow setup is more challenging.

Since combination sleepers experience multiple pressure points and spinal angles, they benefit from a mattress that adapts to different positions. A bed with balanced support and responsiveness, like a hybrid mattress with foam and coils, can provide both contouring and stability.

Pillows also play a big role in combination sleeping. A medium-height pillow for both side and back sleeping can help maintain comfort through position changes, while a supportive mattress ensures smooth transitions between movements.

Once you know your natural tendencies, you can focus on maintaining good posture within your position to improve comfort and long-term spinal health.

How to determine your sleep position

Knowing how you sleep is the first step to improving sleep quality and reducing discomfort. Your sleep position impacts how your body is supported, how pressure is distributed, and whether your spine stays aligned properly. Many people assume they sleep in a particular way, but your actual sleep position might differ from what you think.

If you’re not sure which position you favor, try these methods to figure it out:

• Pay attention when you wake up: The position you’re in when you wake up is often the one you spend the most time in during the night.
• Check for pressure points: Notice any areas of stiffness or discomfort. Shoulder pain often signals side sleeping, while lower back discomfort might indicate stomach sleeping.
• Ask a partner: If you share a bed, ask your partner to observe how you sleep throughout the night.
• Use a sleep tracker: Some sleep-tracking apps and devices can monitor movement and give insights into your preferred positions.

Once you’ve identified how you sleep, you can improve posture and find the right sleep setup to reduce pain and promote better rest.

The role of body weight in choosing the perfect mattress firmness

When finding the right mattress for back pain relief, your body weight plays a big role. It impacts how much pressure your body puts on the mattress, affecting how well it can support you.

Here’s a quick breakdown of how different body weights generally interact with mattress firmness:

Less than 130 pounds: Lighter folks generally don’t sink too deeply into their mattress, so a softer one usually works well to keep your spine aligned while giving that "cloud-like" comfort. Think of it as the Goldilocks zone, just the right cushion.

130 to 230 pounds: Welcome to the "most of us" category. If you're in this weight range, it’s a bit trickier. Too soft, and you might sink in too much (hello, back pain). Too firm, and you might not get enough cushioning, especially around pressure points. A medium-firm mattress tends to be the go-to for most.

230 pounds and more: If you weigh over 230 pounds, you’ll probably want something firmer to keep your lower back and hips in check. Softer mattresses might let you sink too much, which could mess with your spine alignment. A firmer mattress provides the resistance to keep your body properly elevated and aligned.

Bottom line: if your mattress firmness and body weight aren’t in sync, you might wake up with aches and pains. Sleep well, stay aligned!

What the experts say about mattress firmness

We all know a good night’s sleep starts with the right mattress. Dr. Kevin Lees, director of chiropractic operations at The Joint Chiropractic, recently shared his expertise with Better Homes & Gardens on picking the right firmness to keep your spine happy. Here's the expert scoop:

Stomach sleepers: “If you are a stomach sleeper, then a firm mattress can provide the extra support needed to keep the spine in as neutral a position as possible,” says Dr. Lees. “A mattress that isn't supportive, that feels too soft, can add stress to the natural curve in the lower back and the extension and/or rotation of the neck in a person that sleeps on their stomach.

Back sleepers: “Back sleepers will likely get the best balance of support and cushioning from a medium-firm mattress,” says Dr. Lees. “If the mattress is too firm, then there may be gaps in support where the mattress no longer touches the entire body. This can also create pressure points and may add stress to the spine and hips.”

Side sleepers: Dr. Lees notes that “Side sleepers tend to have more pressure on their shoulders and hips. Their ideal mattress is still supportive, with enough cushion to accommodate those areas. Typically, a side sleeper will prefer a semi-firm mattress or a firm mattress with a pillow-top.”

Dr. Lees clarifies that proper spinal alignment is key to avoiding back pain, and choosing the right mattress is step one.

Common myths about mattress firmness and back pain

There are many misconceptions about mattress firmness, especially regarding back pain. Let’s debunk a few:

Myth 1: Firmer mattresses are always better for back pain.

While a firmer mattress can benefit some, it’s not always the best option. The key is finding a mattress that supports the natural alignment of your spine.

Myth 2: Softer mattresses cause more pain.

Softer mattresses can benefit side sleepers, as they cushion the shoulders and hips. The right level of softness can prevent pressure points and provide relief.

Myth 3: You can’t go wrong with a medium-firm mattress.

While a medium-firm mattress works for many people, it’s essential to consider your sleep position, body weight, and personal preferences.

Tips for choosing the right mattress firmness for battling back pain

So…What is the best mattress firmness for back pain?

Unfortunately, there isn’t one magic mattress firmness chiropractors recommend for everyone who experiences chronic back pain. When selecting the right mattress firmness to alleviate back pain, there’s no one-size-fits-all answer. Your ideal mattress combines factors like sleep position, body weight, mattress type, and personal preferences. That said, here are some practical tips to help guide your decision:

Tip #1: Consider your sleep position

Back sleepers often benefit from a medium-firm mattress. This level of firmness provides enough support to keep the spine aligned without sinking too much. A mattress that’s too soft can cause the lower back to curve unnaturally, while one that’s too firm can lead to pressure points.

Side sleepers typically need a mattress that offers soft to medium firmness, allowing their shoulders and hips to sink in slightly. This helps maintain a neutral spine position and reduces pressure on sensitive areas like the hips and shoulders.

Stomach sleepers generally require a firmer mattress to prevent the spine from sinking too deeply and creating an unnatural arch. A firmer surface can keep the body aligned and provide the necessary support for the lower back.

Tip #2: Account for your body weight

For lighter individuals, a medium-soft to medium mattress tends to be a good choice, as it provides just the right balance of comfort and support. A firmer mattress might feel too rigid and not offer enough contouring.

For those over 200 pounds, a firmer mattress is often a better fit. It offers the support needed to prevent sinking too deeply, ensuring you get the right resistance. And be sure to look for high-density support layers for durability that lasts.

Tip #3: Material matters

If you're leaning towards a memory foam mattress, look for one with a medium to firm firmness rating. Memory foam is great at contouring your body’s shape, but ensuring enough support is vital, especially for back and stomach sleepers.

Choose one that balances comfort and support with a medium-firm feel for a hybrid mattress with foam and innerspring coils. Hybrids provide good airflow, support, and cushioning, which can help alleviate back pain for various sleep positions.

Latex mattresses offer a firmer and more buoyant feel, which makes them a good option for people with back pain. Choose a medium to firm latex mattress to align the spine without too much sinkage.

Tip #4: Consider a mattress with adjustable firmness

If your pain fluctuates or your sleep preferences change, an adjustable air mattress made by companies like Sleep Number, Airpedic, Night Air, or iSense may be the best option. With adjustable air mattresses, you can customize the firmness on each side, making it ideal for couples with different sleep preferences or those dealing with evolving back pain.

Tip #5: Test before you commit

Always try out a mattress before committing, if possible. Many mattress stores offer 30-, 60-, or 90-day trial periods, allowing you to sleep on the mattress for a few weeks to see how your back responds. During this trial period, pay attention to how you feel when you wake up. It might be worth considering a different firmness or mattress type if you have stiffness or discomfort.

The best mattress firmness for your back pain comes down to you. Your body knows what it needs, so listen to it. Play around with firmness and mattress types to find that sweet spot for perfect alignment and support while you sleep.

The information, including but not limited to text, graphics, images, and other material contained on this page, is for informational purposes only. The purpose of this post is to promote broad consumer understanding and knowledge of various health topics, including but not limited to the benefits of chiropractic care, exercise, and nutrition. It is not intended to provide or be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Always seek the advice of your chiropractor, physician, or other qualified health care provider with any questions you may have regarding a medical condition or treatment and before undertaking a new health care regimen, and never disregard professional medical advice or delay in seeking it because of something you have read on this page.