Is Your Back Pain More Than Muscle Strain?

Reviewed by: Dr. Steven Knauf, D.C.

By: Janett King

Back pain is common, but that doesn’t make it simple. Nearly 59 percent of Americans have experienced pain in the past three months. For 39 percent, that pain affected the lower back in ways that disrupted routines, limited movement, and interfered with daily life.

While many people experience back pain at some point, not all back pain comes from the same source. Some discomfort comes from a muscle that’s been pushed too far. Some stems from the joints that help your spine move. And some pain can trace back to the nerves that control your muscles and help your body function.

Understanding the difference matters. When you know how to listen to your body and recognize when pain might be more than a strained muscle, you can take proactive steps that may help you feel better faster and move with more freedom and confidence.

This guide walks you through how to identify muscle strain, recognize signs of deeper spinal or neurological involvement, and explore how chiropractic care may help when back pain becomes more complex.

Back pain can come from muscles, joints, discs, or nerves. This guide helps you understand when your pain may be more than a simple strain, how to recognize the signs of something more serious, such as a herniated disc or nerve compression, and what steps you can take to find relief.

What is a muscle strain in your back

A muscle strain happens when your muscle fibers stretch too far or tear. This usually occurs when a muscle is forced to contract suddenly or is overloaded during movement. In the back, this is often caused by heavy lifting, repetitive twisting, or movements that catch your body off guard.

Muscle strains tend to cause localized pain. You may feel soreness, tightness, or a dull ache that intensifies when you use that part of your body. The affected area might be tender to the touch, and you might also notice stiffness or a limited range of motion. In some cases, your back may feel weak or slightly swollen.

The good news is that muscle strains often heal on their own. Mild to moderate strains usually respond well to rest, heat, and cold therapy, as well as gentle movement. Most people feel better in a few days and notice significant improvement within one to two weeks.

If your symptoms are not improving or seem to be getting worse, there may be something else going on beneath the surface.

Signs your back pain is more than a muscle strain

It can be easy to assume that all back pain comes from overworked muscles, especially when it shows up after physical activity or a long day of bending or lifting. But your spine is a complex structure that relies on a combination of muscles, bones, joints, discs, and nerves working together. When one part of that system is out of balance, pain can present in ways that look or feel like a basic strain.

Recognizing the signs of something more involved helps you take action sooner and may help prevent pain from becoming chronic.

Here are some of the clearest signs that your back pain may be more than muscular:

The pain has lasted longer than expected

If your pain persists beyond seven to ten days without signs of improvement, your body may be signaling a more complex issue. At this point, it’s helpful to understand the difference between acute and chronic pain.

Understanding acute back pain vs chronic pain

Acute back pain typically lasts from a few days to a few weeks. It often improves with rest, gentle movement, and supportive care. Chronic back pain lasts longer than three months and may involve deeper structural changes, nerve irritation, or degenerative conditions in your spine. Recognizing when pain shifts from acute to chronic is a crucial step in obtaining the right support and preventing long-term disruption.

You feel pain that radiates away from the spine

Pain that travels from your lower back into your buttocks, thighs, or legs is a key sign of nerve involvement. Sciatic nerve irritation is a common cause of this kind of radiating pain, often described as sharp, burning, or electric.

You experience numbness or tingling

Sensations like pins and needles, tingling, or numbness in your legs or feet often indicate that a nerve is being compressed or irritated somewhere in your spine.

Your strength or coordination feels off

Muscle weakness, balance issues, or difficulty walking may suggest nerve compression that’s affecting the signals between your spine and the rest of your body.

Your pain is worse at night or during rest

Muscle strains usually feel better with rest. Pain that intensifies while lying down, sleeping, or remaining still may indicate joint dysfunction, inflammation, or spinal degeneration.

These patterns help differentiate muscle strain from more serious conditions. When you recognize these signs early, you can seek support that aligns with your needs and helps your body recover more efficiently.

Other causes of back pain beyond muscle strain

Back pain that does not resolve quickly may involve more than your muscles. It may stem from structural, neurological, or even inflammatory changes that affect how your spine moves and functions. Several other conditions could contribute to persistent or disruptive pain. Some of the most common include:

Spinal disc problems: Your vertebral discs sit between the bones of your spine and act as shock absorbers. Each disc has a soft inner core surrounded by a tougher outer shell. When a disc becomes damaged, it can bulge or rupture, placing pressure on nearby nerves. This is known as a herniated or bulging disc and often causes sharp, radiating pain, especially in the lower back. Lower back pain is often the first and most noticeable symptom, particularly when it extends into the legs or feet.

Common symptoms of a herniated disc include lower back pain, numbness, tingling, muscle weakness, and limited mobility. If the herniation affects the sciatic nerve, you may also experience sciatic nerve pain. This type of pain often feels sharp or electric and may worsen with certain movements, such as coughing or prolonged sitting.

Facet joint dysfunction: Facet joints are small stabilizing joints located at the back of your spine. They help control movement and provide flexibility. Over time, these joints can become irritated, inflamed, or degenerate. This leads to localized pain, stiffness, and discomfort when twisting, bending, or extending your back.

Sacroiliac (SI) joint pain: The sacroiliac joint connects your sacrum (the base of your spine) to your pelvis. When this joint becomes dysfunctional or inflamed, it can cause pain that mimics muscle strain but may also radiate into your hips, thighs, or groin. Activities such as standing from a seated position, climbing stairs, or prolonged standing may exacerbate the discomfort.

Spinal stenosis: This condition occurs when the space within your spinal canal narrows, often due to age-related changes like bone spurs or thickened ligaments. Spinal stenosis can compress the spinal cord or nerve roots, causing pain, numbness, or weakness, particularly in the legs. People with stenosis often notice relief when leaning forward or sitting.

Degenerative disc disease: As spinal discs lose hydration and elasticity over time, they become less effective at cushioning the spine. This can lead to pain, reduced mobility, and inflammation. The discomfort often worsens with activity and improves slightly with rest, although it may never fully subside without proper care.

Vertebral compression fractures: Often associated with osteoporosis, these small fractures can occur in the vertebrae and may cause sudden, sharp back pain that worsens with movement or standing. These are more common in older adults and are often underdiagnosed.

Spondylolisthesis: This condition happens when one vertebra slips forward over the one below it. It can result from degenerative changes, congenital defects, or trauma. Pain may radiate and often worsens with activity, particularly with spine extension.

Myofascial pain syndrome: While technically muscular, this chronic pain condition involves trigger points and fascial restrictions. It can mimic deeper spinal issues and doesn’t typically resolve with general stretching or activity modifications alone.

Inflammatory conditions (such as ankylosing spondylitis ): These are less common but important to include. Inflammatory arthritis that affects the spine can cause chronic stiffness, especially in the morning, and tends to improve with activity. Early diagnosis is crucial for managing disease progression.

Postural syndrome or mechanical back pain: This is related to habitual poor posture or repetitive stress. While it may begin as muscular, over time it can contribute to joint dysfunction, nerve irritation, and structural imbalance.

Referred pain from visceral organs: Issues in the kidneys, pancreas, or gastrointestinal system can sometimes present as mid-back or low-back pain. These sources are less common but should be considered when pain patterns don’t align with musculoskeletal causes.

Each of these conditions presents differently, but all share one key trait: they involve structural or neurological elements that go beyond muscle strain.

Nerve pain in your back: What it means

Nerve pain in the back often presents as sharp, shooting, or electric sensations. Unlike muscle strain, this type of discomfort tends to follow specific nerve pathways, often moving from the spine down through the limbs.

When nerves become compressed, irritated, or inflamed, the resulting pain can feel significantly different than a muscle strain. This is because nerves don’t just signal pain. They also carry motor signals to your muscles and sensory information back to your brain.

When your nerves are affected, you may feel pain in places that aren’t even injured. That’s because the nerves branch out and travel through different parts of your body. For example, a pinched nerve in your lower spine can cause pain that travels through your hip and down your leg.

Here are symptoms that suggest nerve involvement:

• Sharp or shooting pain: Nerve pain often feels sudden, sharp, or electric. It may come and go or follow a specific path through your limbs.
• Tingling or numbness: These sensations may come with movement or at rest and often signal that nerve signals are being disrupted.
• Muscle weakness: You may feel that your legs or feet are not responding the way they usually do, especially when climbing stairs or standing for long periods.
• Burning or hypersensitivity: Some people report feeling a burning or raw sensation that does not match the level of activity they’re doing.

These are signs that the source of your discomfort is not limited to soft tissue or muscle fibers. Instead, they point to an underlying disruption in how your nervous system communicates with your body.

How chiropractic care may help back and nerve pain

When back pain goes beyond a simple strain, chiropractic care offers a natural approach that supports spinal alignment and nervous system function. Instead of masking symptoms, chiropractors assess how your spine, joints, and muscles are moving and identify areas where mobility is limited or alignment is disrupted.

When your spine shifts out of its optimal position, joint misalignment can alter movement patterns, increase tension in surrounding muscles, and place added pressure on nearby nerves. Chiropractic adjustments help restore joint motion and spinal alignment, which may relieve back pain, reduce inflammation, and improve overall mobility.

Here’s how chiropractic care may support recovery from more complex back pain:

• Restore joint motion: Gentle adjustments help address joint restrictions that may be contributing to pain or altered movement patterns.
• Reduce nerve irritation: By improving spinal alignment and reducing joint dysfunction, chiropractic care can help alleviate pressure on nerves, thereby easing symptoms such as radiating pain or tingling.
• Support muscle balance: When your spine is aligned and moving properly, the muscles surrounding it do not need to overcompensate. That means fewer spasms, better posture, and more efficient movement.
• Encourage healing: Adjustments help support neurological function, which may help your body move through its natural healing process more efficiently.

Chiropractors work with your body rather than against it, supporting your ability to heal and function with less discomfort and more resilience.

What to do if your back pain does not go away

You know your body better than anyone. When something doesn’t feel right, it’s worth paying attention. While many muscle strains improve with rest and time, lingering pain, neurological symptoms, or disruptions to your everyday movement deserve a closer look.

If you’re unsure about your symptoms or want help determining whether your pain may be more than muscular, chiropractic care offers a proactive next step. A chiropractor can assess your spinal alignment, examine how your joints are functioning, and help you decide on the most supportive course of action.

You don’t need to wait until the pain becomes severe. Addressing it early could help you move more comfortably, recover faster, and avoid more serious issues down the road.

If your back discomfort has lasted more than a few weeks, it may be transitioning from an acute injury to ongoing back pain. Identifying this shift early can help prevent chronic back pain from limiting your quality of life.

The information, including but not limited to text, graphics, images, and other material contained on this page, is for informational purposes only. The purpose of this post is to promote broad consumer understanding and knowledge of various health topics, including but not limited to the benefits of chiropractic care, exercise, and nutrition. It is not intended to provide or be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Always seek the advice of your chiropractor, physician, or other qualified health care provider with any questions you may have regarding a medical condition or treatment and before undertaking a new health care regimen, and never disregard professional medical advice or delay in seeking it because of something you have read on this page.